Add to Favorites
Mail to a friend
Bookmark this page
Print this page
Share on Facebook
Del.icio.us
| Sponsored Links | ||
| Bolongo Bay Beach Resort Fun, friendly beachfront resort with a Caribbean flair. One of-a kind All Inclusive plan with 100% a la carte dining, and also Eurpean Plan rates. | Hillcrest Guest House Book 3 days and get 1 FREE, 10% off Nov. | Virgin Islands Campground Eco-sensitive Cottages each with an ocean view |
|
|
You are viewing only dining reviews. Click here to view all reviews.
 Blackbeard's Restaurant is closed. |
|
| Posted by info253 | |
|
This fine old restaurant is now just a tourist attraction open only when ships are in. Go to Bluebeard's Castle for dining. Hope this saves you a wasted taxi ride. |
| 1 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
Did you find this helpful?   | |
| It was poorly managed. |
|
| Posted by brian_bl37 | |
|
The manager misrepresented himself several times. This place is over priced. There are lots of other places to enjoy a meal and a drink in the Caribbean. |
| 0 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
 Don't bother. |
|
| Posted by saintthomasbound | |
|
It is highly overrated and expensive. The staff and management here are rude. |
| 0 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
 This is our favorite on the island. |
|
| Posted by saintthomasbound | |
|
You owe it to yourself to dine at this restaurant! It's by far the best one at Bluebeard's, and my personal favorite on St. Thomas. The staff is warm and welcoming, and the food is creative and delicious. In addition, the ambiance of the restaurant itself is beautiful with the table cloths, intimate seating and a view that can't be matched. The wine selection is massive, and the owner comes to your table to be sure that your time in his restaurant is all it can be. I love it! |
| 1 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| They have great food. |
|
| Posted by cps | |
|
Enjoyed the food here. |
| 0 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| It was not worth the visit. |
|
| Posted by davesnothere | |
|
The title says it all. |
| 1 users found this review helpful. 2 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| This was the best we had in St. Thomas. |
|
| Posted by davesnothere | |
|
The title says it all! |
| 1 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
 It was not worth it. |
|
| Posted by davesnothere | |
|
I had expected something special. The host, Craig, had no personality, and I did not feel welcomed. There was no atmosphere, and the food was nothing special. There are better places just around the corner. |
| 2 users found this review helpful. 2 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
 It was A plus! |
|
| Posted by tippjim | |
|
Duffy's Love Shack has good food. |
| 1 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| We had a great dinner here. |
|
| Posted by 2stillscratchinginse | |
|
I stayed at the resort this restaurant is associated with. I had the stuffed Caribbean lobster for dinner for our anniversary. It was so good, I am still thinking about it! The bartender from Rhode Island during the day was fun, and she did a great job. |
| 1 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| We had a very disappointing experience here. |
|
| Posted by jillybean1947 | |
|
We read the ads for the Old Stone Farmhouse Restaurant and decided it would be a good choice for dinner one evening while spending a week in St. Thomas. What a disappointment! Yes, the historical significance of the property and the ambience were fascinating. However, the food was absolutely terrible. The first three courses were so small (about two bites in each one), and for the most part tasted bad. My husband and I both got the lamb for the main course, and it tasted awful and was very fatty. Even the wine was awful. How can you ruin a glass of Pinot Noir? After the dinner, we had such a bad taste in our mouths so we asked for mints. They said they couldn't give us any, but gave us sorbet. It also tasted terrible. We couldn't finish it. We were both up sick at least half that night. Needless to say, we won't go back. I can't believe that awful meal came to over $170.00! |
| 1 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| We had a wonderful dining experience. |
|
| Posted by jillybean1947 | |
|
We have been visiting St. Thomas for the last eight years. We have two favorite restaurants, and one of them is Herve. We love the ambience, the service, the view, and the wonderful food. Also, the wine is exceptional. Herve is there to pleasantly greet us. We can't wait to return. |
| 1 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| Off the Hook offers waterfront dining with great presentation. |
|
| Posted by tjstock | |
|
This is white table cloth dining on the water. The food was very good with a wonderful presentation. It was a little on the pricy side - but worth it. |
| 0 users found this review helpful. 2 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| We love Havana Blue! |
|
| Posted by skeezixk9 | |
|
We discovered Havana Blue during our first visit to St. Thomas in 2005, and absolutely loved it. My husband, my teen son and I each had the lobster - pricy, but absolutely delicious. The view of the water is stunning, with an occasional cruise ship passing by. On our last visit, I discovered their blueberry and vanilla martini. We will be returning there in a few weeks, as this is now a regular stop for us. |
    |
|
| 1 users found this review helpful. 1 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| The food was good, but the waiters were terrible. |
|
| Posted by cathy | |
|
The food was great, but we had a waiter here one night who was terrible. It did not seem to matter to him if he was good or not - since the tip was automatically added to the bill (that was a wooping 18%!). Not the next time! The girl who waited on us was great - and she did not add the 18%. |
| 1 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| It's not Mafolie - go to Greenhouse Restaurant. |
|
| Posted by lindalee | |
|
It is located on the waterfront in Charlotte Amalie. Ask for Carolyn or Marvin as your waitstaff. I can't say enough about them. They also offer two-for-one drinks and reduced priced appies during happy hour. Also, they serve the best french onion soup in the islands. In addition, they have very good chicken nachos, conch fritters and jerk chicken wings. Pina coladas are outstanding here, too. |
| 3 users found this review helpful. 3 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| You can enjoy good food and fun at Molly Molones. |
|
| Posted by chuck | |
|
Molly Molones, in the Red Hook area, is one of our favorites. It's a fun place with good food and reasonable prices. |
| 3 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| I loved it! |
|
| Posted by tedjamie | |
|
I had snacks and drinks at Molly Malones. They had great food, and it was clean and fun! |
| 1 users found this review helpful. 0 found this review unhelpful. | |
| Did you find this helpful? | |
| Sponsored Links | ||
| Bolongo Bay Beach Resort Fun, friendly beachfront resort with a Caribbean flair. One of-a kind All Inclusive plan with 100% a la carte dining, and also Eurpean Plan rates. | Hillcrest Guest House Book 3 days and get 1 FREE, 10% off Nov. | Virgin Islands Campground Eco-sensitive Cottages each with an ocean view |
