We had an amazing time at Coyaba over Christmas 2022. Everything was better that we imagined. The views are the highlight, and the space is perfect and so comfortable! Would rent again and again and again.

Andrew and team were amazing and responsive to any and all needs we had. We felt so at ease knowing they were a call away.

Coyaba is a beautiful villa! The amenities were excellent and the pool was perfect for dipping after a fabulous day on the beach. The views were beautiful - some of the best I’ve seen since visiting the island. All the bedrooms were cozy and comfy, and AC throughout the house was a game changer! It made the mornings so much more enjoyable. Highly recommend this house and working with Betsy was a dream and eazy peazy! Can’t wait to return!

Excellent! Super helpful and she was so prompt with messages/questions/requests.

The week started off a little rough with a broken air conditioning unit for the Master Bedroom portion of the main house. Once that was repaired, everything else was perfect. From the second you pull onto the driveway, the views hit you. Whether it’s the house, the Caribbean, the mountains. They are all spectacular. The house itself had everything anyone would need (from the kitchen, to the great room to the bathrooms). The pool deck had everything (plenty of seating, pool floats, beach chairs and a cooler). And the view - WOW. Loved standing in the pool at the infinity edge, listening to the waves crashing below you and watch the world go by. There were a couple of days when an Iguana joined us. He just sat there on the edge of the pool and sunbathed. Obviously this was a regular occurrence because he was not bothered by us at all.
The house is very private. There are other houses around you but nothing right on top of you. You feel like you are at your own resort. The complex consists of 3 separate buildings - the main house has the kitchen, great room, a couple of separate sitting area’s, the Master bedroom and 1.5 bathrooms. The other 2 bedrooms are in separate pods and have their own fully stocked beautiful bathrooms. The only downfall to the pods are they do not have TV’s. Not a huge deal for us because our daughter’s used their laptops.
One other selling point are the circular, stone showers. Just beautiful.
Will definitely return.

Betsy and the entire Where to Stay Team were all great to deal with. From the Taxi service at the airport to the greeter at the dock on St. John who also happens to be your tour guide to your house and walks you through the house. All top notch.

My family and friends rented this villa the week of July 9, 2022. This place has the most amazing views and the house we perfect for all of us. I would definitely rent it again.

Shawna is amazing. We have worked with her in the past and she is great. I will work with her in the future for my next Villa trip. Thank you Shawna for always being so helpful.

Our stay in Coyoba Villa was ideal for our family of 4 (2 adults and 2 adult children). There were beautiful views from everywhere. A equipped kitchen and multiple dining spaces for when we are at home. We really enjoyed the Infiniti pool and even managed to find a few shady places outside when the UV Index was high. The en-suite sleeping areas had similar features (such a cool stone shower) so there was no arguments who had the better rooms! The beds and linens were so comfortable!

We had a few maintenance issues during the week but they were quickly resolved. The communication with the staff was fantastic from the moment we inquired about renting. It was a fabulous vacation for our first time on STJ.

Betsy and the rest of the staff at WhereToStay was fantastic from beginning to end.

Everything was perfect!! Only one complaint. For $8,000 a week, we would have really liked to have comfortable beds with suitable pillows.

Other than that, lovely!! Beautiful view, lovely home, good location…

The Coyaba Villa was Perfect!! The view is spectacular!! We loved the infinity pool and the outside area was great for spending the afternoons relaxing and watching the sunset. The Villa was very spacious and the kitchen was amazing and very well stocked. We absolutely loved our stay at Coyaba Villa and would highly recommend.

Betsy was amazing to work with. She was very easy to contact and organized. She made booking the Villa very simple and stress free. I would highly recommend working with her and would book again.

You will not find better service or a better house that is fit for 3 couples. Unbelievable.

Working with Shawna and WhereToStay.com was awesome!

Coyaba villa is absolutely beautiful with amazing views. The infinity pool made you feel like you were drifting into the ocean. The bedrooms were beautiful and spacious and the stone showers
made you feel like you were outdoors. Five star !!!!
One thing I would add are TV’s in guest bedrooms

Shawna was great, always helpful and sweet.

There were 4 of us staying at this villa and we were blown away with the how beautiful it was. The architecture in this home is just gorgeous. The uniqueness of the bedroom pods was something we have never encountered before. The infinity pool was amazing. We also liked where it was located, as it was not super close to other villas and private. We would definitely stay here again should we ever get a chance to return.

The booking process was so easy and the concierge staff, Betsy, Sharon and even the villa local managers, were so pleasant to deal with. I would like to send an extra thank you to Betsy for all her help and feedback for this trip. We would definitely use Where to Stay again for any of their villas that are listed. Thank you Where To Stay!!

View was absolutely awesome! Separate bedroom pods were great. Villa needed some TLC. Kitchen lacked as there were no baking dishes at all. The hood above the stove was dripping water. Need additional beach chairs and the ice chest handle was broken. It would also be nice to have updated beach towels as many were fringed and had holes. We were very impressed with management as twice we had to call and our issues were immediately resolved. We would definitely stay at Coyaba again as it fit our family of six perfectly, but would love to see these issues taken care of.

Perfect!

I would like to give this house 5 stars, but I can’t. It was a great house, but two of the three bedrooms had a moldy smell and the house flooded during a rainstorm, resulting in water in each bedroom and the master bath. I had to wade through water to dry out my luggage. To our relief, the property managers were quick to respond and dried it up quickly so we could get on with our day.

The house is in a great location, and it’s a nice size for accommodating a family. The furnishings were good and there were plenty of towels.

Our booking experience was excellent! Shawna was wonderful and super easy to work with! We highly recommend WhereToStay!

WhereToStay.com’s Response:
This, unfortunately, was an isolated incident during a rainstorm after hurricane’s Irma/Maria when there was no vegetation to soak up the water from the hills.

From the outside this villa is lovely but unfortunately the inside has been neglected.
Granted we arrived in some heavy rains but walking into leaking roofs, and doorways was unsettling. The gentleman (Bernard) who escorted us from the car rental to the property was gracious and stayed to help mop the floors and lay out rubber mats but every time it rained that week we were cleaning up. Wet tile floors are dangerous.
The air conditioning problem in one of the pods, as well as the WI-FI was remedied the following day.
We discovered after Bernard left that the front door is not secured and has been in this state for ‘a few years’. Reasoning stated that it’s from Germany and they’ve been having trouble fixing it. Guessing that’s why he took us in through the kitchen sliders. Main house/bedroom could not be locked.
The kitchen is well equipped and the welcome food was thoughtful and appreciated.
Plenty of beach/bath towels, chairs and coolers. We’d like to suggest new mattresses, pillows & linens considering the $$$ nightly rate.
Dear owners
Please consider some of our suggestions to improve your property especially the front door and water leaks.

Shawna and her team were responsive and a pleasure to work with.